After enough years building screen enclosures across Northeast Florida, certain misconceptions come up again and again. Here are the ones we hear most, and the more accurate version of each.
Myth 1: “A Screen Enclosure Makes My Pool Completely Childproof”
A pool cage adds a real, meaningful layer of protection — a continuous screened barrier with a self-latching door is genuinely more protective than a wide-open pool deck. But it’s not automatically a substitute for Florida’s required pool safety measures, and it’s a layer alongside direct supervision, not a replacement for it. We’ve written in more depth about where pool safety requirements and screen enclosures intersect and which door hardware features matter most for families.
Myth 2: “Wood Framing Is Just as Good as Aluminum Here”
Some older structures around Jacksonville still have wood-framed screen rooms, and a few builders will still offer it. But Florida’s humidity, rainfall, and termite pressure are exactly the conditions wood struggles with long-term, while aluminum doesn’t rot or attract termites and needs far less upkeep. See our full breakdown of why aluminum wins in Florida’s climate.
Myth 3: “I Don’t Need a Permit for a Small Enclosure”
Size doesn’t exempt a structure from permitting. Every screen enclosure in Duval, St. Johns, Clay, and Nassau County — large or small, new build or rebuild — requires a permit and has to meet current wind load engineering. Skipping it is one of the most common and costly mistakes homeowners make. Read more in our permit guide and 7 common screen enclosure mistakes.
Myth 4: “Aluminum Rusts Just Like Steel in This Climate”
Aluminum and steel behave very differently in humid, salty air. Unlike steel, aluminum doesn’t rust — it’s corrosion-resistant, not corrosion-proof, which is a real distinction but a much better starting point than steel. The biggest threats to an aluminum frame’s longevity are actually clogged structural gutters and untreated coastal salt exposure, not rust in the way people picture it. More detail in why aluminum is the Florida standard.
Myth 5: “All Screen Mesh Is the Same”
Standard fiberglass mesh is the right default for most homes, but it’s not the only option — and it’s not always the right one. No-see-um mesh, pet-resistant mesh, privacy screen, and different mesh colors all serve different situations, from preserve-backing lots to homes with dogs that like to lean on the screen. Our screen mesh guide breaks down which type fits which scenario.
Myth 6: “A Reputable Contractor Will Build Off the Books to Save Time”
A legitimate, licensed contractor doesn’t offer this, because an unpermitted enclosure can complicate a home sale, may not be covered after storm damage, and can require expensive retroactive permitting if it’s ever discovered. If a contractor suggests skipping the permit, treat that as a red flag rather than a convenience.
Get the Straight Answer for Your Project
We’d rather walk you through the real facts during a free estimate than let a myth shape your decision.
Questions about your specific project? Call Kish Enclosures at (904) 805-4343 or request a free estimate online.